TV episode review: Star Trek - The Original Series “The Empath”
-
by Clare Siobhan
The “alien torture chamber” episode
Summary:
Kirk, Spock, and McCoy suffer torture and manipulation at the hands of powerful captors who want to elicit a response of compassion from an on-looking mute alien who can absorb others’ pain.
As a character study and an examination of loyalty and self-sacrificing friendship in the Kirk/Spock/McCoy trio, this episode excels. There are numerous character-revealing moments as each man in turn offers himself to save the others. This episode also offers interesting parallels with modern issues of medical ethics and contains several Christian symbols and thematic elements.
Story synopsis:
Kirk, Spock, and McCoy beam down to a planet in a solar system in which the sun is about to go nova, an event that will destroy all the planets orbiting it. Their mission is to evacuate the members of a scientific research team who have been studying the star as its destruction approaches.
Some of the planets in the system are inhabited. Two beings, called Vians, capture Our Three Heroes and place them in confinement with a girl who can’t speak but who can sense their emotions. She can also take their physical pain and injuries into herself and dissipate them—she is a being known as an “empath.” They realize that in absorbing the injuries of another person, the empath could actually physically endanger herself, but they assume that in such an event her instinct for self-preservation would prevent her from going that far. McCoy names her “Gem”.
The Vians are aware of the impending destruction of their solar system. They say they have the power to transport the inhabitants of only one planet to safety. The Vians torture first Kirk and then McCoy because they want to see if, during her time with the three men, the empath develops a willingness for self-sacrifice that overrules her instinct for self-preservation. Only then, the Vians insist, will she prove her planet and her people worthy of survival.
As McCoy lies dying from his torture-induced injuries, the Vians tell Kirk and Spock that during their captivity “everything that is truest and best in all species of beings has been revealed by you. Those are the qualities that make a civilization worthy to survive…” If Gem’s planet is the one that will be saved, the Vians must make certain they are worthy of survival. “Her willingness to give her life for him will prove this.”
Story analysis:
This is one of my favorite episodes of Star Trek, but I do have one problem with it. The Vians’ claim of a “one planet limit” is arbitrary and unconvincing. Throughout the episode the Vians display their incredible power to conjure up any object or bring about any circumstance they desire to elicit a reaction from their subjects. If they’re so powerful, why can they not transport the inhabitants of all the planets to safety? Or why couldn’t they have contacted the Federation years ago to launch a massive solar system-wide evacuation?
Am I nitpicking? Perhaps. But the reasons and motivations in a story like this should be airtight, and they’re not. I just don’t buy this “one planet limit”.
But I’m willing to put aside my incredulity in order to examine the Vians more closely. They possess unspeakable power, and unspeakable arrogance. They think they can declaim from on high which planet’s population they will save. A population must first prove itself “worthy” to be saved.
This is sick.
But isn’t this is the way human beings, particularly scientists, think? Modern scientists have the power to create human life in their laboratories AND the power to decide which of the lives they create are worthy to be saved. Medical doctors decide whose “quality of life” is “acceptable” enough to justify to continuing treatment.
The day is already here when the severely disabled can be put to death for the crime of being a burden to society or to their families. To some, they are no longer “worthy” to be saved.
The day is coming when even lives conceived naturally will have to prove themselves–pass a genetic screening test in order to be deemed “worthy” to live. (Or perhaps to receive coverage from a health insurance provider…) Those who do not pass muster will be selectively aborted or consigned to liquid nitrogen. (Or denied coverage…) It’s already happening with increasing frequency: the April 2007 issue of The Atlantic (p36) reported on an EMBO paper called “The Future of Neo-Eugenics”. According to The Atlantic report, approximately 6120 Down syndrome babies are conceived each year in the United States. Of these, nearly 30% are aborted. Overseas the percentages are higher: 32% in Western Australia and over 80% in Taiwan and Paris.
“Prenatal screenings will grow more comprehensive and may eventually cover all known disease genes,” says the report.
The power of a geneticist or a fertility specialist is as high above the human embryo’s capabilities of defending itself as the Vians’ power is above Kirk, Spock, and McCoy. So too is the power of a doctor or judge above the capabilities of the severely disabled.
(To read The Atlantic’s summary report go here and scroll all the way down to the last article. The EMBO paper is available for purchase at this website.)
But let’s turn the tables. What if the Vians were to analyze the population of planet Earth in the early 21st century? What would they find? A planet full of people who, like the empath and like Kirk, Spock, and McCoy, are willing to endure suffering, pain, and even death for one another? Or would they find a population of people whose “instinct for self-preservation” dominates to such an extent that we pursue our own ambitions, agendas, momentary pleasures, economic interests, conveniences and material comforts at the expense of others? Does the modern human race demonstrate “everything that is truest and best in all species of beings?” Do we possess the qualities that make a civilization worthy to survive?
If our star was about to go nova would the Vians bother to save us?
How blessed we are that the real Savior of our planet knows we could never prove ourselves worthy, yet still values and loves us despite our sinfulness. “But God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us.” (Romans chapter five, verse eight)
Christian elements:
This episode contains several recognizably Christian symbols and thematic elements. Perhaps some of them were not inadvertent:
• When Kirk, Spock, and McCoy arrive in the Vians’ underground laboratory/torture chamber, they find Gem lying on a platform, which is shaped like a cross.
• The torture of Kirk and Spock involves hanging them up in a cruciform posture, by the wrists.
• McCoy’s injuries – congestion of the lungs, bleeding into the chest and abdomen, severe heart damage, massive circulatory collapse – are consistent with the injuries suffered by victims of crucifixion.
• In the episode’s coda scene aboard the Enterprise, Mr. Scott declares that Gem was the “pearl of great price” featured in the story of the merchant (Matthew 12:45-46).
• Kirk, Spock, McCoy, and Gem demonstrate the virtue of self-sacrifice. Gem even takes on the wounds of the ones she is to save: see Isaiah 53, especially verses 4-5.
Favorite moment:
One of the ways the Vians torture and test Our Three Heroes is by giving Captain Kirk a choice between sending McCoy to the torture chamber next, which will likely kill him, or Spock, who will be brain damaged and permanently insane.
McCoy and Spock argue over which one of them will go—each insists on himself being the one to go with the Vians. But Kirk tells them that the decision is his and his alone.
As medical treatment for the injuries Kirk suffered at the hands of the Vians, McCoy administers a sedative to the Captain. Spock then informs McCoy that since the Captain is now incapacitated, he is in command and that his command decision is to go with the Vians instead of McCoy.
Spock sits down and continues adjusting a piece of equipment in order to devise a means of escape. The empath approaches Spock and just looks at him, evidently liking what she sees: she fixes him with a gaze of tender admiration tinged with humor, as if to say, “Ah, I see through your impassive mask and sense beneath it a soul of deep feeling and unshakable virtue, which I admire very much.” The moment passes quickly, but it demonstrates that skillful storytellers develop character not only by that character’s dialogue and action, but also by other characters’ reactions to him or her.
McCoy then sneaks up on Spock and gives him a sedative. A moment after Spock, still protesting, drops unconscious to the floor, the Vians appear and take McCoy away to be tortured.
Favorite quotes:
McCoy: “I can’t destroy life, even if it’s to save my own.” Touché. Interesting tie-in here with embryonic stem cell research, abortion, and euthanasia of humans. Also, McCoy has a telling flashback in Star Trek V: The Final Frontier that makes this line of his all the more poignant.
Kirk, addressing the Vians: “Love and compassion are dead in you. You’re nothing but intellect.” Could we not address in this way the scientists who manipulate embryonic human life and who promote abortion and euthanasia of human beings?
McCoy: “I’m a doctor, not a coalminer.”
“The Empath“
Original airdate: December 6, 1968
(Star Trek: The Original Series, 3rd season)
63rd episode produced
67th episode aired
Written by Joyce Muskat
Directed by John Erman
Comments(0)